Is interpersonal group work better than sitting meditation for training mindfulness?
Originally added on Fri, 18/11/2011 - 06:26Last updated on Thu, 08/12/2011 - 06:17
I'm missing the seventh session of the Mindfulness-Based Stress Reduction course that I've been attending because I've come down to our annual four day UK Men's Group in Cumbria. I've written about these peer groups many times on this blog - for example, last year's Men's Group and the year before's, as well as Mixed Groups here in Cumbria and just last month a Scottish Mixed Group too. I woke this morning and wondered - as a kind of thought experiment - whether maybe this four day interpersonal group is, in some ways, a "better" way of training mindfulness than the more traditional practice of sitting in meditation.
Peer groups: Scottish Mixed Group – final morning
Originally added on Wed, 19/10/2011 - 05:30Last updated on Tue, 01/11/2011 - 05:46
The final morning of the group. Still strong feelings settling from the evening before. Caring for each other. Re-strengthening the group "container". We wobbled a good deal later on on Sunday, but I think everyone can feel good about "keeping the show on the road". Potentially very helpful learning.
Peer groups: Scottish Mixed Group – second full day: bumps, maintaining the group, emotions & cognitive processing
Originally added on Tue, 18/10/2011 - 05:22Last updated on Wed, 09/11/2011 - 06:48
I wrote in the last blog post about the first part of the second full day at Glassie. Later on in the afternoon we moved into a more "bumpy" phase of the group. Often in these more difficult interactions there is the richest learning for everyone involved if one has the courage and openness to digest what happened. Irvin Yalom, in his research on process groups, found that best outcomes were associated both with a great deal of caring, empathy & emotional "holding" and also with a great deal of "chewing over" and trying to understand what was brought up by events in the groups. Interestingly, and in contrast, best outcomes were associated with a medium level - not too much & not too little - conflict & challenge.
Peer groups: Scottish Mixed Group – second full day: emotional ‘cooking’ in the group, and personal work too
Originally added on Mon, 17/10/2011 - 05:19Last updated on Tue, 08/11/2011 - 06:12
I wrote yesterday about the first full day of this "long weekend" residential peer group. The second day of the weekend was particularly rich - very nourishing or a bit too much depending partly on one's digestion. So after the usual walks, talks, meditations, long chatty breakfasts, we began again in the full group at 10.00am. Often at these residentials we start the morning with small support groups before moving on to the full group. Over these three days we've reversed this sequence, starting with the full group and then, after a coffee break, moving on to the small support groups. Both ways of organizing things have their benefits. Yesterday starting with the full group worked particularly well. As so often happens, one of the everyday experiences of living with others for three days had pushed buttons for someone, open
Peer groups: Scottish Mixed Group – first full day: small support & full group work, gender ‘fishbowls’
Originally added on Sun, 16/10/2011 - 05:17Last updated on Tue, 01/11/2011 - 05:42
Again it's a little before 6.30am. Pitch black outside. I wrote yesterday morning about the first evening of this group. We then went on to the first full day.
Peer groups: Scottish Mixed Group – beginning, initial thoughts, exciting & edgy
Originally added on Sat, 15/10/2011 - 05:14Last updated on Tue, 01/11/2011 - 05:41
About 6.30 in the morning. The lights of Aberfeldy shining through the dark from down in the valley. We're at Glassie Farm Bunkhouse - fourteen of us staying here for three days. I've written about this kind of peer group residential on a whole series of occasions on this blog - for example a UK Mixed Group in Cumbria this spring and a UK Men's Group in the Peak District last autumn. The UK Men's Group, which has been running annually since 1993, spawned a Scottish Men's Group a good few years' ago, but the UK Mixed Group, which has been running since '91, never followed suit until now.
Peer groups: Cumbria spring group – reflection
Originally added on Thu, 12/05/2011 - 09:07Last updated on Tue, 07/06/2011 - 05:48
Back from the four day peer group in Cumbria. Back into the rich, busy, fascinating river of 'everyday life'. I've written already about the last full day of the group in "Vision express & where are these groups going?" and, as well, about confrontation in "Authenticity, learning & interpersonal conflict". The last morning of the group was good too, with a dip in the stream and a final breakfast, a group meeting with appreciations, learnings, and then to tidying up, lunch, leaving. Driving North again through Spring sunshine and showers. Precious times.
Peer groups, Cumbria spring group – fourth morning: 'vision express' & where are these groups going?
Originally added on Sun, 08/05/2011 - 05:24Last updated on Fri, 29/07/2011 - 04:29
So how was yesterday? In the blog post "Peer groups, Cumbria spring group - third morning: authenticity, learning & interpersonal conflict" I talked about conflict & confrontation. I think I jumped in too fast and too hard a couple of days ago in a small group interaction that sparked some difficulties we went on to work with yesterday. Good intention, good work. Things have moved forward it seems. Teasing out the issues, being honest, hearing each other, apologising for unnecessary hurt. And it seems to me, it's well worth going back again to speak more about it ... to see where we've got to in our individual processing of what happened. There's potential learning here for me, for the other person, for our relationship.
Peer groups, Cumbria spring group – third morning: authenticity, learning & interpersonal conflict
Originally added on Sat, 07/05/2011 - 06:02Last updated on Tue, 07/06/2011 - 04:50
Have I screwed up? I wrote yesterday about the first full day of this peer residential group. I woke this morning with wisps of cloud in my mind ... a flash of Lady MacBeth ("out, damned spot") ...
Peer groups, Cumbria spring group – second morning: early stages of a group, self-disclosure, & emotional awareness
Originally added on Fri, 06/05/2011 - 05:41Last updated on Fri, 29/07/2011 - 04:30
I wrote yesterday about arriving at this year's Mixed Group here in Cumbria. Now it's the second morning. Yesterday was the first full day of the group. How was it? As I've written before "Process groups tend to move through a series of developmental stages. These can be described in a variety of ways. Tuckman presented an early description which still contains much that is useful. His sequence was forming (orientation and dependence), storming (intra-group conflict and differentiation), norming (interpersonal intimacy and cohesion), performing (work and functional role-relatedness), and adjourning (loss and autonomy). It is important to emphasise that all stages of group development contain useful opportunities for learning and that one stage is not necessarily any better than another."